Arsenal suffered a significant setback in their quest for silverware, falling 2-0 to Newcastle United in the first leg of their Carabao Cup semi-final at the Emirates Stadium. This defeat marked Arsenal’s first home loss since April 2024 and highlighted Newcastle’s emerging status as a formidable opponent for Mikel Arteta’s side. Alexander Isak, a player previously linked with a move to Arsenal, proved to be the Gunners’ nemesis, netting his seventh goal in five games to give Newcastle the lead. This came shortly after Gabriel Martinelli had struck the post for the home side, underscoring the fine margins that ultimately decided the match. Anthony Gordon then doubled Newcastle’s advantage, capitalizing on defensive lapses to further compound Arsenal’s woes. Despite creating numerous opportunities, including a glaring miss by Kai Havertz, Arsenal were unable to breach Newcastle’s resolute defense, leaving them with a considerable uphill battle in the second leg.
Newcastle’s victory was their first at the Emirates since 2010, solidifying their reputation as a bogey team for Arsenal. The Magpies, eager to secure their first major trophy in 70 years, displayed a determined and clinical performance, effectively neutralizing Arsenal’s attacking threats while capitalizing on their own chances. Isak’s goal, a well-taken finish from close range, showcased his growing confidence and ability to find the back of the net. Gordon’s contribution further demonstrated Newcastle’s attacking depth and their capacity to punish defensive errors. This victory sets the stage for a highly anticipated second leg at St. James’ Park, where Newcastle will look to protect their two-goal advantage and secure their place in the final.
The individual performances of Arsenal players reflected the team’s overall struggles. David Raya, despite showing moments of nervousness, was largely blameless for the goals conceded. Myles Lewis-Skelly, an academy product, continued to impress with his composure and defensive contributions, earning the highest rating among Arsenal players. However, defensive lapses from Gabriel and William Saliba allowed Isak the space to score, while Jurrien Timber was caught out of position for Gordon’s goal. Furthermore, Timber missed a golden opportunity to equalize from close range, further highlighting Arsenal’s profligacy in front of goal.
In midfield, Thomas Partey and Declan Rice provided a solid foundation but lacked the creative spark to unlock Newcastle’s defense. Martin Odegaard, despite being closely marked, showed glimpses of his quality but was unable to exert his usual influence on the game. Gabriel Martinelli’s direct running and positive play offered a threat, but his finishing touch deserted him on the night. Leandro Trossard’s contributions were limited, while Kai Havertz’s anonymous display was compounded by a glaring miss from close range.
The introduction of substitutes Jorginho and Gabriel Jesus in the second half injected some much-needed energy into Arsenal’s attack, but they were unable to make a decisive impact. Oleksandr Zinchenko’s late cameo was marred by a rash challenge that earned him a booking, summing up a frustrating night for the Gunners.
Newcastle’s tactical approach, characterized by disciplined defending and efficient counter-attacking, proved highly effective against Arsenal. Their midfield, led by the tireless Joelinton, effectively nullified Odegaard’s influence, disrupting Arsenal’s build-up play. The Magpies’ defense, marshaled by the commanding Sven Botman and Dan Burn, stood firm against Arsenal’s attacking forays, limiting their clear-cut chances. Furthermore, Newcastle’s ability to exploit set-piece opportunities, as demonstrated by Isak’s goal, highlighted their tactical awareness and preparation.
The result leaves Arsenal with a significant challenge in the second leg. They will need to produce a vastly improved performance at St. James’ Park to overturn the two-goal deficit. This will require greater clinical finishing, improved defensive solidity, and a more effective strategy to break down Newcastle’s organized defense. The pressure will be on Arteta to find the right formula to inspire his team and keep their hopes of silverware alive.
For Newcastle, the victory provides a significant boost ahead of the second leg. Their resolute defensive display and clinical finishing have given them a valuable advantage. They will be confident of completing the job at home and securing their place in the final. The second leg promises to be a captivating encounter, with both teams battling fiercely for a place in the Carabao Cup final. The pressure will be on Arsenal to produce a comeback performance, while Newcastle will be determined to maintain their advantage and progress to the next stage of the competition.
